I knew that you'd come back with too dry and too crunchy but didn't want to ask if that was the case before hearing your take. I've been there with the overcook but you can't tell it's going to be turn out that way just by looking at it. This also comes back to cooking the pie on the stone, something that I used to always do but have gotten away from to just shorten up the time the oven is on. I've never overcooked the pie when using a stone but placing directly on the center rack of the oven I have had it turn out too dry and crumbly.
The cheese sounds like just low-moisture, part-skim mozz and not some type of low fat mozz. Nothing wrong with low-moisture, part-skim mozz, it's all I use. My experience with some pre-shredded low-fat mozz, that I bought accidentally, was that it definitely did not melt nicely. In fact, I think it just got warm, keeping that same shredded form. Nasty.
Loo
Good advice, thanks loo. It's warming up here and I am trying to avoid that hour preheat too so will take it easy on the next one, which will be this weekend if not sooner. Looks like I will going with the cast iron again since a decent deep dish pan is just not be had locally and I'm itchin' to have another go at one of these. So I stopped at the deli and that Galati cheese is gone but I bet you are correct on that too.
Can I ask you about any tips for adding veggies? I once got an unbaked loaded from Uno's (franchise location) and it ended up pretty wet when I baked it.
Thanks All
Hog