The 14.5" pizza stone kits that BB&B sells come with an 11" peel. I've somehow ended up with three of them and they are useless for most of my needs. Wish I could just hand you one. Not sure why in the world they put an 11" peel in a box with a 14.5" stone.

Because those "kits" are Made in China! In other words, it's crap.
I'd rather invest in some imported European and well-known American brands than buying anything from stores such as Bed, Bath and bull%$#&, Target, K-Mart or Macy's. Not to mention Williams-Sonoma and Pier One.
The few dollars more, you'd have to dish out, are well worth it.
Mike