Here we are, two Old Forge girls, born and raised, to solve your Old Forge Pizza Mystery.
However, the only true answer to your question lies in a trip to Old Forge for a taste of the best pizza on the planet (outside of Italy).
Having moved to the great city of Philadelphia to pursue our careers, the next best thing to seeing our families is coming home for pizza. We've never been able to find a substitute for pizza made in one of the great OF restaurants. Even in the 5th largest city in the nation, there's not a single pizza that can top it!
The closest we have found---outside the Vatican. And, "Made to Travel OF Pizza", packed in dry ice and shipped to Philly! GO, EAGLES!
You're right-they are trays, not pies...cuts, not slices...and the cheese is a secret Old Forgers take the the grave!
Each sauce has a distinct flavor...aged perfectly like Grandma Annie at Revello’s! Our favorites are too numerous to mention.
But if you take the tour don't miss Revello's...where a salad with cheese is a great pizza accessory
Cafe Rinaldi's...where there is an amazing Risotto special.
Arcaro and Genells...where every OFHS grad proudly holds their celebration.
Mary Lou's...a take home favorite.
Salernos...where we've all had our very first dates and you are invited into the kitchen to pick up your pizza.
Ghigiarelli’s...where our parents and grandparents remember going for pizza and beer when was 15 cents per cut
Anthony's and Brutico's...which also offer a taste of fine dining.
Maxies...hidden off the Main Street but and excellent choice.
Talarico's...a lunchtime favorite.
And Rossi's Market...not just a supermarket, but a secret location of excellent OF pizza!
Old Forge Pizza Gurus