John, in the other thread, Chau expressed an interest in having one from each of these styles:
slice, old school ny, np, hybrids, or coal
Here's my preliminary recommendation:
slice - ?
old school ny - Pizza Town or Best (or both)
np - Barboncino
hybrids - Vesta? Paulie Gee?
coal - ?
Barboncino is appealing because many of us haven't been there and I've heard good things about it. Differentiating between 'old school NY' and 'slice' is tricky for me, because I tend to combine them. I consider Pizza Town a 'slice' place, but I'm pretty sure both you and John Conklin probably put it in a different class. Best is also a bit tricky to classify.
If everyone REALLY wants to go to Totonno's, I'll tag along, but I was thinking that Chau could cover coal on his own with a subway ride up to Patsy's
Those are my thoughts, but, honestly, I think, when it comes to Brooklyn, we should probably be asking you where to go.