I am holding a small jar of Penzey's Pizza Seasoning as I type, the ingredient list reads: salt, fennel seed, oregano,sugar, garlic,black pepper, basil,onion, crushed red pepper and Cayenne red pepper. I bought it out of curiosity on a visit to the Grand Central Mkt. Penzey's location (since closed), and have not been impressed with it at all. I can easily and much more cheaply make my own mix, and for sure it would not contain sugar or Cayenne red pepper. I would assume others have reached the same conclusion.