I like the subtle version. The basil, cheese and sauce already have a strong impressionistic quality (especially the basil) and the filter enhances that.
I'm traditionally pretty anti-filter and almost always find them cheese-y, but here, maybe. Whatever you go with, I'd sleep on it, at least a couple nights. I don't think you can make decisions like these quickly. You've got to take the image in and let it incubate.