I've ordered from Penn Mac and been pleased. However, this weekend I visited their store in the Strip district of Pittsburgh. If you are nearby, it's certainly worth a visit. They have a great selection of Italian foods and a terrific deli, with good prices (especially on meats and cheese) compared to what I can get in the Washington DC area. The selection in the store is better than what they show online. Plus, shopping in the Strip is fun, you can have an "almost famous" sandwich from Primanti's and pick up lots of cheap Steeler's swag! Here's a snapshot of my loot: