Wow, how about that! If memory serves, going back to the 1960's that place would be known as Tahiti East
Anyway, curious, I jumped on the phone and spoke to an nice earnest young man asking him what type pies they made. Neopolitan. I asked? No, sir..he said. Oh, okay then what are they like? NY style ? I tried. No sir. . They're small , he said ,thin crust serves one person. Uh-huh. How long do they bake, I continue ? About 90 seconds he said.
The Pie Boy could have said nothing and been nice.......but I did try my very best to at least be tactful and said , Oh, okay, so they are Neopolitan pies. Okay, he said.
So Pine Brook isn't Naples, yet.
The place looks like a lot of fun, the few pie photos on their website look good, and for those wanting NP in that part of NJ, it may be worth trying. My personal taste are still NP-challenged so I'll probably not see you there. In that neck of the woods, the place I hanker for is Reservoir Tavern..hope it's still good.