My current favorite pizza restaurant is Abbot's Pizza
, just down the street from my house, which is a fortunate accident for me. (BTW, they really don't have their own website.) They only have stools for seating, but they have a high turnover, and so there are always new pizzas being made. The bulletin board is rather amusing also.
Alternatively, I also like Italy's Little Kitchen
, but I'm more likely to order calzone there. I like the 1950's home photos of the daughters in prom dresses from Elizabeth, New Jersey - it creates an interesting homey atmosphere.