I don't have access to Jersey Fresh, they are not sold where I live, however, a very well known name in NYC pizza circles tried Jersey Fresh and Sclafani side by side for me and his opion was that the Sclafani's were better. They could both be from the same canner and harvest, might be slightly different consistency, no body knows! If you like them, buy them. Another very good brand of canned Jersey grown tomatoes is La Fede. I just recently tried them, they are sold in my area through Shop-Rite Markets. Seems as though Jersey tomatoes rank right up there with the best of Italy or California.