A couple thoughts on the menu:
That's a lot of pies. My suggestion would be to start with 4-5 max. Not counting sub-ingredients, I counted ~35 ingredients on your menu. That seems like a lot to store, prep, manage.
Pepperoni - have to have it.
Margherita - have to have it.
Quattro Formaggio - more cheese bread than pizza. My guess is you don't need this pizza. If you do, since your not doing traditional cheeses anyway, why not do LM and fresh mozz (looks like you have both already), parm, and cheddar/ That way you can ditch the ricotta (which will be a pain) and prov which you probably don't need.
Veggie Max - do you really need it, or are you trying to be all things to all people? Without this pie, you eliminate a lot of prep and a lot of ingredients that loose freshness quickly, particularly when prepped.
Big Maui - same comments as the Veggie Max. What makes it "Big?" What makes it special?
Spicy Salami - same comments as the Veggie Max. Why do you need this and the red Diavola? Of all the pies on the menu, to me, this is the one that most screams "get me off the menu."
Esquelto - another one with a lot of ingredients, including 5 orphans, and a lot of prep.
The Diavola twins - does every ingredient need to be ghost pepper? Realistically, how many of these will you sell? That's a lot of unique ingredients in those two.
My suggestion would be to figure out exactly who redbeard pizza is and start with Pepperoni, Margherita, and two pies that define Redbeard. Three at most. Make the pepperoni and margherita both "yours." Get rid of the ones that don't scream Redbeard. You can always add more later as you figure things out more. Doing a few things exceptionally well, even if you don't offer everything everyone wants, will serve you better in the long run than doing too much and not doing it as well - or worse, just being average. You're not competing with PJ's or Dominoes, so don't. If you let yourself get drawn into competition with them, you'll lose.
How are you coming up with your prices? I see you already took a price increase. How do you know what is the right price or that you're not too high/low?
One last thought, have you tested how well your pizza travels? Be sure to have your taste testers try everything you decide to menu after being held 10 minutes in whatever box/insulated bag combo you plan to use. If 3rd party delivery won't have insulated bags, be sure to test it that way too. It's not going to be the same pizza when delivered. High temp pizza doesn't hold like an American-style gut bomb.