Peter,
I'm happy that there are people doing the research into sourdough cultures and bacteria. I think that there is still a lot that we don't know, which keeps this pursuit interesting.
hb
""people's

doing the research into sourdough cultures and bacteria.""
exactly, that's why im doing my lil test now to solve for my self how true/false it is...
i started my Ischia SD Starter yesterday, and to keep it clean i sterilized very old flour so i didnt have to worry about contaminants....
i started with and will be feeding it AP (old, very old) that i put in the oven at 250f and left it for 40 min then let it cool down to 190f for about 1 1/2 hours then jared.
4 cups of de-yeasted, de-molded and de-fungied feeding flour..
lol, (i dont want to add any yeasts beside the unavoidably airborne stuff til i get a fully working Starter going!) to it so ill do the same cooking on the HW and Cuputo from time to time...
kept below 266f so i didnt denature the proteins....
Boiled Well Water, and kept my fingers crossed...
well it took off great so i guess i didnt kill the cooked flour..
so as i was doing this i said to myslef, self, nows the perfect time to do this simple and easy test...
i have 40g out side in an big wide tupperware with no lid... sitting on the porch..
in a week ill add 40g W and at the same time take 40g from the closed cooked feeding flour and start a match jar, and to be funner ill do a jar with the HW i got a month ago and the last one from a 55lbs cuputo blue i just got still unopened in the shipping box Original packing not a repak....
i statred my Ischia.... Working Great...
soon ill start just to see and compare...
1. the porch "air yeast on the wind" on cooked/cleaned flour
2. the jar'ed clean/cooked feed flour
3. the reg store bag HW
4. the middle of the bag cuputo
After the Ischia is going full and in frige land doezzzing, a week or so, ill start theses and do them all the same...
i think
1. "who knows what will grow from it"
2. starial..... wont do a thing...
3. should work just fine
4. should work just fine
damm ill have 5 starters if i do this and i still have a another culture in the frige..
i wont be keeping them much long at all unless i get a really good kicker outa one of them..
science at its finest..
Slack...