I'd like to join the chorus of thank yous for your work and willingness to post the results. I grew up in NEPA, and while Ceccoli's was and remains my favorite when I get back for a visit, it never really dawned on me that it would be possible to make the style at home. I'm a pretty adventurous cook and baker, but it seemed that there must be some secret that put it beyond trying it at home. Maybe that VP and Ceccoli's prosper with strange hours, long waits, and cash only policies...
Anyway, my third try is in the oven. A few little tweaks because of preferences - 6 in 1 crushed tomatoes, a mix of sharp provolone and mozz, a splash of fish sauce and black pepper in the sauce. It is about the crust. To my taste, neither VP nor Ceccoli's (where the pizza looks like it's topped with stewed tomatoes) have a sauce/cheese combination that is so great it's worth sticking to exactly.
My husband is also a fan, although he grew up in Albany, NY. He says that a Troy pizza joint made this style, but that wasn't true when we stopped there recently. Maybe it has changed over the years, but now it's just an average medium thick square pizza.
Anyway, thanks!